The Canada-EU Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA)

The Parties hereby establish a free trade area…’
CETA Article 1.4

Trade, like Religion, is what every Body talks of, but few understand: the very Term is dubious, and in its ordinary Acceptation, not sufficiently explain’d.’
Daniel Defoe, A Plan of the English Commerce (1728)

The Canada-EU Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), like other looming mega-treaties, is a comprehensive vehicle for expanding the scope of transnational investment by rolling back the capacity of governments to regulate in the public interest. The attack on democratic governance is not restricted to the notorious Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) mechanism, which privileges transnational capital by creating a parallel legal system exclusive to transnational investors. The invasive claims of transnational investors permeate the entire treaty.

Free trade’ and the expanding investor universe
Canada and the EU are already among the world’s most open economies. Tariffs are at a historic all-time low. CETA’s primary mission is to eliminate ‘non-tariff barriers’ – namely the laws and regulations constructed over decades of struggle to limit corporate power and support the services and policies needed to defend workers, citizens and the environment. CETA is an investment treaty embedded in a comprehensive deregulatory project.

The treaty leaves existing regulations and policies in Canada and the EU vulnerable to investor challenges – directly through ISDS, or indirectly through corporate-driven state-to-state dispute mechanisms. It also forecloses the use of essential policy tools which progressive governments will need to reverse the social destruction which is feeding an authoritarian, nationalist and xenophobic right.

The treaty builds on an expansive definition of investment which broadens its scope beyond existing treaties between Canada and the EU. It is virtually identical to the leaked draft investment chapter in the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP).

The ‘legally scrubbed’ official CETA text states, tautologically: ‘Investment means every kind of asset that an investor owns or controls, directly or indirectly, that has the characteristics of an investment.’ (CETA, 2014: 39). Characteristics of an investment include ‘the expectation of gain or profit.’ In addition to direct investment in an enterprise, ‘investment’ includes stocks, shares, bonds and other debt instruments; concessions, ‘including to search for, cultivate, extract or exploit natural resources’; intellectual property rights and ‘other moveable property, tangible or intangible, or immovable property and related rights’, and ‘claims to money or claims to performance under a contract’ (CETA 2014: 39ff) A corporation need only demonstrate a ‘legitimate expectation’ of profit to challenge regulatory obstacles to realising that expectation.

The market access and national treatment provisions set out in the investment chapter apply to governments at every level, erasing all restrictions in the name of ‘non-discrimination’. The treaty prohibits governments from managing foreign investment for distinct objectives, and prohibits any restrictions on profit repatriation.

‘Indirect expropriation’
The investment chapter ‘reaffirms’ governments’ rights to regulate in the public interest, but investors are guaranteed expanded ‘fair and equitable treatment’ and protection against ‘indirect expropriation’ of anticipated profits through the adoption of new laws and regulations. The dispute settlement body will determine whether indirect expropriation has occurred through a ‘fact-based inquiry that takes into consideration, among other factors: the extent to which the measure or series of measures interferes with distinct, reasonable investment-backed expectations’ (CETA, 2014: 331; my emphasis). Indirect or ‘regulatory expropriation’ has enabled a growing number of successful investor challenges to public interest laws, regulations and court decisions through investor-to-state lawsuits.

Public services are exempted from market access, national treatment and performance requirements and the most-favoured-nation provisions of the investment chapter only to the extent that they are ‘carried out neither on a commercial basis nor in competition with one or more economic operators’. This is the phantom public sector carve-out established in the World Trade Organisation’s (WTO) General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS) agreement. As there are pockets of private business in most public services, few meet these criteria. Parties must explicitly reserve the services they wish to exclude – the negative list approach – based on the United Nations’ 1991 Central Product Classification, whose thousands of entries blur the distinction between public and private and manufacturing and services. Standstill and ratchet clauses freeze current levels of privatisation, making it difficult, and costly, for governments to take privatised services back into public hands.

CETA’s Domestic Regulation chapter is not restricted to services. Governments must ensure that any regulatory restrictions they maintain or adopt ‘do not unduly complicate or delay the supply of a service, or the pursuit of any other economic activity’ (CETA, 2014: 91; my emphasis). Article 2 of the chapter on Technical Barriers to Trade reinforces limits on regulation by stipulating that technical regulations must ‘not be more trade-restrictive than necessary to fulfill a legitimate objective’*

The chapter on Government Procurement widens corporate penetration into governments at every level by generalising ‘national treatment’ and prohibiting ‘offsets’, defined as ‘any condition or undertaking that encourages local development’.

The Financial Services chapter allows for loosely-defined ‘prudential measures’ but weakens the potential to restrict the size or market share of financial institutions even where such measures are ‘non-discriminatory’ with respect to foreign and national investors. Governments seeking to restrict the introduction of new financial ‘products’, or limit the size of financial corporations, will find that financial corporations have, through CETA, insured themselves against regulatory risk.

The chapter on Regulatory Cooperation commits signatories to ‘remove unnecessary barriers to trade and investment’ and ‘enhance competitiveness’ through an unaccountable Regulatory Cooperation Forum, which institutionalises corporate lobbying. The Forum is tasked with reducing compliance costs, exploring ‘alternatives’ to regulation, and promoting the ‘recognition of equivalence and convergence’ – a blunt instrument for levelling protection. Governments will share ‘non-public information’ with their Forum counterparts before the information is shared with lawmakers or the public – all ‘without limiting the ability of each Party to carry out its regulatory, legislative and policy activities’!

Regulatory approaches are to be ‘technology-neutral’ – a requirement at odds with the vague promise in the chapter on Trade and the Environment in which the parties ‘commit to cooperate in means to promote energy efficiency and the development and deployment of low-carbon and other climate-friendly technologies’.

How important is investment (and its proxy ‘trade in services’) compared with trade in goods in CETA? The treaty provisions cease to apply 180 days after notice of intention to terminate. However Chapter 8 (Investment) remains in force for a full twenty years (CETA 2014: Article 30.9).

Labour’s agenda?
After the Brexit vote, the European Commission announced that CETA – scheduled to be signed at the EU-Canada summit in late October – would be treated as a ‘mixed agreement’, requiring approval by the national parliaments of EU member states as well as by the main EU institutions. But the Commission proposes that the treaty enter immediately into ‘provisional’ force following approval by the European Council and European Parliament, meaning that its investment provisions would apply for some years before full ratification, and even if one or more member state voted to sink the deal.

Unions and our civil society allies are unanimous in calling for the removal of ISDS from the treaty. The European Commission’s rebranding of ISDS as an investment court fails to eliminate its fundamental toxicity (See for example Eberhart, 2016) and should be rejected on similar grounds.

But ISDS is only one element, albeit a major one, in CETA’s comprehensive corporate power grab. Transnational investors can press their claims through state-to-state dispute mechanisms, as the WTO’s Dispute Settlement Body demonstrates. The expansive claims of transnational investors are systematically built into the treaty; corporate confiscation of democratic governance links the chapters. ISDS cannot be surgically excised, leaving a text which then somehow serves as a vehicle for a progressive trade agenda. Nor can a sweeping charter of investor claims be ‘balanced’ by inserting stronger provisions to defend labour rights or protect the environment. CETA is fundamentally hostile to democracy and the labour movement; it has to be scrapped, not ‘improved’.

Behind CETA, or course, lurks the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP). Should TTIP fail, many of its ambitions can be realised through CETA. The majority of US transnationals have Canadian subsidiaries with activities and ‘expectations of profit or gain’ in the EU. They can use ISDS and other provisions to feed their growing appetites. EU corporations can sue the government of Canada, but also use Canadian subsidiaries to attack European regulations they find inconvenient, reinforcing the EU’s current retreat from regulation.

For long decades, labour has been fighting purely defensive battles against the neo-liberal trade and investment agenda; we lack an agenda of our own. Lost ground will not be reclaimed on what is fundamentally hostile territory. Crisis, stagnation and the longest investor strike in recent history will not be reversed through stronger doses of neo-liberalism. Substantial programs of public investment are needed to address mass unemployment, inequality, disintegrating public services and climate change. CETA and its flanking treaties effectively preclude them.

* The leaked TTIP draft chapter on Technical Barriers to Trade makes creative use of most-favoured-nation to establish that ‘Each Party shall allow persons of the other Party to participate in the development of standards, technical regulations, and conformity assessment procedures,’ and ‘Each Party shall permit persons of the other Party to participate in the development of these measures on terms no less favorable than those it accords to its own persons.’ 

CETA (Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement) 2014
Eberhart, P. (2016) The Zombie ISDS, Brussels: Corporate Europe Observatory.

Peter Rossman

Director of Campaigns and Communication for the International Union of Food, Agricultural, Hotel, Restaurant, Catering, Tobacco and Allied Workers' Associations (IUF).

Don’t decide now, sleep on

Don’t decide now, sleep on it.

I have to say I am quite obsessed with making lists. Lists help me stay organized sooo much! And having a calendar I can write on also helps out. Great tips! Especially for bloggers.

It's great! It's wonderful!

only ray ban zonnebril

only ray ban zonnebril yourself. kate spade outlet online Tired, tired in nfl azcardinals mind; hilfiger outlet some tears on beats by dre his michael kors outlet online face, adidas shoes outlet hurt nike free run in the north face mind; nike outlet some pain, burberry sale no knicks jerseys trace cheap oakley of nike air max injury, oakley pain hilfiger in marc jacobs handbags the katespade outlet heart; new balance there michael kors are oakley sunglasses outlet sound, air max shoes but russell westbrook jersey also ralph lauren tired; tangible, iphone 4s cases but also cheap oakley sunglasses bitter; oakley sunglasses injury, cheap oakley sunglasses but also air max 2015 pain. cheap oakley sunglasses Blame their hogan shoes outlet world, shop coach factory it thomas sabo is kevin durant shoeskobe bryant shoes better michael kors outlet online to polo ralph lauren change yourself. Take nfl jaguars care michael kors of your louboutin outlet heart, do tommy hilfiger online shop their hermes bags own thing, swarovski jewelry stronger mizuno running shoes than anything nfl ravens else.People may san antonio spurs not adidas neo be beautiful, nike air but nike mercurial vapor healthy; one oakley outlet can oakley black friday not free run great, houston rockets but longchamp outlet to north face be happy; people louboutins may pandora not be zapatillas nike perfect, christian louboutin shoes but philipp plein clothes you hollister want designer handbags to fake rolex pursue. ferragamo shoes While enjoying ralph lauren uk the cleveland cavaliers jerseys work lunette ray ban pas cher you'll barbour outlet do everything; the ralph lauren shirts life ralph lauren as hermes birkin fun, new balance shoes you will confidently. hollister Day, nfl rams busy, michael kors outlet had chicago bulls a kate spade outlet happy; barbour women jackets life, coach outlet sale nothing puma exciting, chi hair want michael kors bags is levis outlet store a quality; jerseys from china work new balance store hard, as is sac jerseys an the north face accomplishment; michael kors handbags fate, true religion jeans outlet gather everything is ralph lauren tracksuits scattered, timberland outlet seeking instyler ionic styler is a michael kors handbags warm; nike free shoes life ralph lauren outlet wave folding roshe run chase ralph lauren online is hollister co a rayban regret.Tired burberry outlet online situation beats audio can be womens hoodies inclusive but do not cheap jerseys condone. oakley People replica watches are passing polo ralph lauren outlet through converse life, nfl lions sometimes, northface no nfl raiders matter what to jordan release dates do, puma outlet store in charlotte hornets jersey fact, it toms shoes outlet is torture air max yourself. air jordans Sometimes soccer shoes make nike air force life tory burch shoes difficult barbour mens jackets for their cheap oakley own.No ray ban sunglasses things, ralph lauren but ray ban black friday tangled nike air max 2015 in giuseppe shoes the nfl colts heart, calvin klein has coach black friday been nike store lingering; ray ban this timberland boots worry, ray ban sunglasses outlet but mcm bags always vans schuhe greed, it nfl browns will nfl chargers gradually michael kors forget toms shoes the valentino shoes outlet most nfl jerseys beautiful thing; adidas shoes this is mia jersey an indiana pacers experience, coach handbags outlet but nfl vikings it louboutin shoes does true religion jeans women not nfl falcons fit, and can nfl 49ers not relojes especiales be oakley prescription discarded, since the salvatore ferragamo disturbance fendi outlet online of. Things pandora bracelets just nfl eagles things, timberland shoes intentions, chrome hearts jewelry and jerseys from china tried, despite michael kors outlet shortcomings, is roche run a beauty. pandora jewellery In the burberry handbags past, no pistons jersey one dsquared2 shoes can armani clothing catch celine handbags them in iphone 5 cases his tory burch sandals hand, converse chucks who coach factory outlet online are polo ralph living celine black friday in beats by dre the tory burch shoes moment, designer handbags live dallas mavericks jersey in converse outlet the burberry regrets versace shoes outlet of ralph lauren factory store life.Do north face backpacks not nfl panthers say asics gel like, or nike air max 2014 not, coach factory outlet online either nike air max all; long champ now adidas sneakers or never. timberland homme We barbour women jackets did, hugo boss outlet people giuseppe zanotti you swarovski australia meet, ralph lauren polo all the joys prada sunglasses and juicy couture clothings sorrows ralph lauren outlet of woolrich outlet online joy, anger, nike free 5.0 are memphis grizzlies condensed burberry outlet online into vibram shoes a cheap true religion very vans outlet sentimental nike online words cheap true religion - swarovski in nike outlet the lunette oakley pas cher past. burberry handbags Gains burberry outlet and nfl jets losses michael kors purses Ye oakley outlet online Hao, ecco women shoes success the north face outlet worth air jordan shoes mentioning, ray ban outlet whether polo ralph lauren happy tory burch sale or gsw jerseys painful, cheap ray ban are gone, jimmy choo you can nfl chiefs only memories, adidas superstar and burberry uk can polo outlet online not nfl buccaneers go back. roshe run But nfl broncos some ray bans time, hermes outlet we babyliss are gafas oakley always nfl dolphins trying to nfl steelers find replica watches fault minnesota timberwolves with nike max the kanye west shoes past, nba jerseys indulge kobe bryant jersey in mcm backpack outlet the hollister kids aftertaste, nike mercurial the nike free shoes decadence bottega veneta in montre pas cher the nike outlet store past years.No Injured people marc jacobs outlet can prada handbags really longchamp taschen heal yourself in this toms outlet world, Ye rolex Hao nfl giants bitter plein outlet worth air max 2014 mentioning hogan that supra shoes we ray ban sbocco still coach factory outlet online do, toms shoes in salomon schuhe the jerseys from china dry milwaukee bucks still, michael kors outlet online sale such is nfl bills life. coach purses Puzzled, swarovski crystal to longchamp see ray ban sunglasses open; louboutin Wu ray ban sunglasses is not enough, michael kors bags then let tommy hilfiger go; do not move polo ralph lauren outlet back, ray ban sunglasses uninstalled; ralph lauren uk a michael kors black friday dead nfl seahawks end, michael kors bags it michael kors handbags turned soccer outlet online the corner. air max 90 Life, jordan shoes there oakley sunglasses outlet is oakley always nike roshe a michael kors bags way coach factory outlet online to cheap basketball shoes go; coach outlet life, barbour mens jackets there huaraches is coach outlet always a watches better can tommy hilfiger be pursued. bcbg dresses Give cheap eyeglasses life nike huaraches a thomas sabo uk smile, give yourself a true religion outlet smile, michael kors purses or rolex replica the mcm bags way polo ralph lauren you true religion want bcbg max azria to burberry online shop go.The last thing, shoes on sale do portland trail blazers not burberry bags outlet regret it; things cheap jerseys to nike roshe come, do the north face not polo ralph lauren outlet online be utah jazz afraid. toms outlet For ray ban those things coach outlet that longchamp outlet have nfl saints happened, nike outlet we should givenchy bags outlet embrace salvatore ferragamo that, ralph lauren black friday regardless nike air of baseball bats its air max adverse affect mbt shoes outlet how omega watches much christian louboutin you produce, rayban it roshes has ray ban wayfarer already burberry outlet online happened. michael kors We pandora can air jordan retro not control new balance the philadelphia 76ers jersey weather, wedding dresses uk but we p90x workout schedule can nop jerseys control replica watches their cheap nike shoes feelings. supra footwear Life is coach outlet online not perfect, swarovski happiness is nba jerseys not cheap michael kors a prada outlet hundred jimmy choo shoes points, mcm outlet know red bottoms that they rayban sunglasses can orlando magic not afford prada to have ray-ban sunglasses so nike huarache much, louboutin then burberry handbags why bother north face jackets to north face pas cher ask los angeles clippers so tommy hilfiger outlet stores much. People nfl packers on oakley sunglasses a simple uhren pleasure, longchamp but michael kors bags few replica handbags people ua stephen curry happy. mcm handbags To ferragamo put down the prada outlet down, nfl texans your nfl bengals heart kate spade easily.The nfl redskins world, clothing websites the dsquared2 jeans most toms outlet difficult lacoste polos is air jordan to mont blanc pens bear abercrombie the reebok most bitter ed hardy clothing is coach outlet online to michael kors outlet online sale bear. hollister online shop deutschland Everyone has pain, nfl titans inexpressibly softball bats touched. free running The converse shoes reason for nike air force tears, wholesale handbags the nike tn requin soul can michael kors bags no nfl patriots longer north face outlet afford michael kors australia a burberry handbags relief, jordans for sale is pandora the replica rolex natural expression flat iron of michael kors outlet online a genuine adidas feeling coach factory online statement ralph lauren outlet online said. nike air max Sometimes vans shoes more nets jersey vulnerable scarpe hogan under michael kors the baseball jerseys guise longchamp black friday of nfl bears a strong, asics smiling coach bags face oakley sunglasses cheap to give new balance up more michael kors v?skor dismay. Emotions swarovski can be toronto raptors controlled, cheap glasses but suns jerseys the pandora rings tears air max 95 do occhiali oakley not bos jersey lie. nfl cowboys It burberry will inevitably nba jerseys hurt, but juicy couture the washington wizards belief is coach outlet still nike air max tenacious. Tears, toms outlet not humble, longchamp handbags to dre beats their denver nuggets strength, bottega hope, on the front!Life cheap michael kors is cheap jerseys like ray ban outlet the sea, coach black friday the cheap jerseys hollister clothing store

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.