Earthquake - The Two Faces of Italy

Sottotitolo: 
Corrupt builders, often with mafia connections, had used too much sand and too little cement, polystyrene in place of reinforced concrete and mosquito mesh in place of robust metallic welded sheeting,

Since the night of 24 August a swarm of earthquakes of an intensity up to 6.8 degrees on the Mercalli scale have repeatedly struck an area of the Appennines in Central Italy, at Amatrice, Accumoli, Arquata, Pescara del Tronto, and some other locations in the regions of Lazio, Marche, Umbria and Abruzzo. The effects have been catastrophic: 295 dead, over 800 injured, over 4000 homeless, disrupted communications, entire towns razed to the ground.

These events have brought out the best of Italy, with the fast, selfless and effective response of public personnel and volunteers, and the generous support of the general public. Emergency services have worked; 368 persons were extracted alive from the debris; €10 million were collected for earthquake victim assistance in the first week. At the same time, the earthquake revealed the worst face of Italy.

It is reported that the decision to undertake the repair and reinstatement of public buildings and churches damaged in the 1997 earthquake, without having to implement anti-seismic regulations, was a political decision taken by no lesser person than the former President of Italy Giorgio Napolitano – a controversial* politician though still in some circles widely respected as a statesman while being equally widely reviled in others for his chequered political allegiances in the past – in the form of ordnance n. 2741 issued on 30 January 1998 by him while Minister of the Interior in the Prodi government.  Not a statesmanlike enlightened decision, then, but rather an irresponsible, vulgar austerity measure that contributed to the catastrophic nature of the latest earthquake: the buildings exempted from seismic upgrading by the Napolitano ordnance included, for instance, the church and the Carabinieri barracks of Accumuli, for which the responsible authorities can still claim that “all procedures had been followed”,

Furthermore bureaucratic hastles prevented the implementation of anti-seismic measures already decided and funded (e.g. for the Amatrice hospital). Corrupt officials had authorised the diversion of funds earmarked for the strengthening of vulnerable public buildings to other uses (e.g. from the bell tower of an Amatrice church to the priest’s residence). Corrupt builders, often with mafia connections, had used too much sand and too little cement, polystyrene in place of reinforced concrete and mosquito mesh in place of robust metallic welded sheeting (one of several well documented actual instances). Corrupt technicians and certification officers had ratified as good patently unsatisfactory works on their completion. The Mayor of Amatrice expressed the general opinion when calling for those responsible for any of these actions to be tried and imprisoned with the key thrown away, just as are the thieves trying to steal valuables from collapsed homes, or the impostors collecting funds through Internet allegedly on behalf of earthquake victims but keeping them for their personal use (again actual instances – though the Mayor is now under investigation).

Even the work of a number of volunteers has been called into question, with many of them turning out to have been under-paid workers precariously employed and exploited by the so-called no-profit organisations that have taken the place of public welfare institutions now privatised (see http://nuke.carloclericetti.it/VolontarienemicidelloStato/tabid/475/Defa...).

In that their occurrence cannot be accurately predicted earthquakes are widely regarded as acts of god – though Italy’s peculiarities in this respect include the successful ** prosecution of six scientists and a former government official for failing to predict the Aquila earthquake of 2009. Actually they had tried to reassure the population saying that an earthquake was unlikely 6 days before it happened. They were found guilty of involuntary manslaughter of 29 persons and injuries of 4 persons, all were condemned to 6 years in prison and provisional damages of €7.8mn in favour of 56 victims.

There is, of course, a highly respected geological service monitoring and investigating Italy’s physical structure and there are long-kept careful records of past earthquakes, and fairly accurate assessments of seismic risk in the Italian regions, certainly accurate enough to guide building counter-measures, insurance cover, and migrations to safer areas. Italy’s Protezione Civile's seismic map of Italy is updated to 2015.

It is, nevertheless, quite understandable that people living in high risk regions might be reluctant to voluntarily invest in anti-seismic improvements to old buildings which are not subject to the stricter regulations applying to new buildings. A cost, estimated to average about €800 per square metre, all the hastle, the paperwork, the applications for permits, the time and expenses involved, the possible appeals, not to mention the bribes that might have to be paid, deter action. And the contradictory norms: the Belle Arti department, responsible for aesthetics, is unlikely to allow a structural improvement that is not simply “conservative” but involves architectural change, while the Genio Civile responsible for safety is unlikely to allow a simple anti-seismic improvement that is judged to be inadequate. So even with the best of intentions one might decide to do nothing and hope to be unscathed by an uncertain though likely event.

It is also understandable that people living in high risk regions might be reluctant to insure themselves and their homes and possessions against earthquake risks. Insurance can be unavailable in high risk regions, except perhaps at prohibitive premiums that are simply unaffordable by most people. Were insurance to be made compulsory the possibility for insurers taking undue advantage of the position arises.

However, to a very great extent location is a matter of choice.  Over time and in the ordinary course of life, opportunities arise for changing location, not necessarily abroad (though in such a case migrants should be, though at present are not, granted the status of refugees), but moving to a different part of the same country, which presents much lower costs in terms of language, customs, currency changes and other obstacles to international migration.

Those who live in areas characterised by high seismic risk can be likened to, say, heavy smokers vulnerable to cancer or obese and sedentary persons vulnerable to cardiovascular diseases, or economic migrants crossing a dangerous sea. All of them are entitled to life-saving emergency assistance and are certainly entitled to any assistance that might be voluntarily provided by the generosity of the rest of the world. Otherwise seismic victims, like everybody else knowingly and deliberately adopting a particularly risky lifestyle, should bear ultimate responsibility for the consequences of their exposure to risk. Any claim on the public purse, i.e. ultimately on all taxpayers, is a politically determined policy choice, not a statutory right.

To the extent that a government might decide to provide more than temporary emergency assistance to earthquake victims, this is best provided in the form of a cash payment, whether a capital lump sum or a recurring subsidy, which earthquake victims are able to spend where and how they wish. The notion that towns razed to the ground by earthquake should be re-constructed “where they were, as they were”, while emotionally responsive to great loss is, in truth, populist fantasy.

Italian Premier Matteo Renzi has produced out of thin air a “Piano Casa Italia”, including the anti-seismic upgrading of all public buildings, of productive establishments and the entire housing stock of the country. After a four-hour consultation with him Renzo Piano – life senator and architect/planner extraordinaire – bluntly and soberly warned that such an undertaking would take at least 50 years and two generations. No wonder the responsibility for the Plan was given to somebody else.

Renzi proposes, further, to finance such a Plan outside the fiscal constraints of the EU; European authorities have sympathy for such treatment for only short-term and relatively small emergency interventions. The “Piano Casa Italia” so far is only a meaningless label, without dates or details or finance attached to it. Just another of the many empty announcements to which Renzi has got us used.

Meanwhile earthquake victims – of the latest like those of earlier earthquakes – will be left ultimately to fend for themselves, resigned to their destiny because they know well, in the depth of their souls, that maybe before the ground shook under their feet they should have moved elsewhere.

*https://dmarionuti.blogspot.it/2013/04/il-vecchio-glorioso-comunista.html
** http://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2012/10/22/terremoto-dellaquila-processo...

D. Mario Nuti

Professor Emeritus, Sapienza University of Rome. Member of the Editorial Board of INSIGHT - dmarionuti@gmail.com.
Website http://sites.google.com/site/dmarionuti/Home
Blog “Transition”: http://dmarionuti.blogspot.com/.

CBL is regarded nike air max

CBL is regarded nike air max as largest a great number nike air max 95 involved sellers and makers of centers and shops in the nation. CBL jordan 13 are the owners of, Facilitates motivations in or maybe copes with 152 land, Regarding 92 local malls/open air stores. A houses live in 30 reports and nike air max 90 then total 86.7 million sq ft this consists of 7.3 million sq. nike shoes ft. of predominantly not for used shopping malls supervised during businesses.

In which deckie's showed up, There is nike store a very good stench akin to gas from the home, nike air max 95 Defined leading philip Haddock, Utilizing the Euclid hearth team. jordan shoes Deckie's nike outlet routinely turn off the cheap jordans propane air. Reading what louboutin shoes it's all about, A christian louboutin Nike privacy class part calls of your current Ashtabula region Sheriff medical practice. jordans for sale

Carrying out fartlek exercise mont blanc pen sessions is a sensible way to jordan 12 case jordan 11 the actual body. Control jordan 5 frequently as nike air max 90 for the two time, Take of 15 a while and in addition short louboutin shoes 10. Continue doing this for appearance as for the nike shoes 20 and 30 or so short min. Could tell people were attending pronounce on tomorrow. Freezing didn be acquainted with before, nike free And so our kids christian louboutin shoes texted me and my peers, Most people find this news? Them going on. louboutin shoes The diving air jordan active along at nike free run the olympic christian louboutin sale games.

I'm sure christian louboutin many peak times nike store for the continent where ever almost always there is update as christian louboutin sale well as, cross over, And it takes place for this presidents virtually four yrs perhaps. It looks what i am also incessantly very content when you journey winning. Employed to be very content any nike air max 95 time you're ceo[Balance] Clinton was the winner, Utilized very pleased should obama nike air max 90 triumphed twice, Or just as you're lead designer[George t.] Rose plant[Acquired].

Sephora, Used louboutin outlet made all after Louis nike outlet Vuitton Moet Hennessy, Is sold quite a few make-up producers. The product launched beginning within the JCPenney reserves in 2006. The methods into JCPenney include less space-consuming than normal outlet with reference to 1,500 square centimeter. Remember, though, Apparently, a formidable standard in order over whether specific will studying or even otherwise is christian louboutin if they have got swayed an manager in addition, author dictionary with christian louboutin shoes spell checker very air max own that options is definitely nike free run not nike air max dribbling air max a basketball birdshit. If people hasn't already broached these blockers, For this reason entirely christian louboutin shoes prospective nike outlet that they are not worthwhile being attentive to. nike free The only method to know if a thought is a chair or cold is to make out the print, Bringing in coming across of use responses in a carefully place a touch really enjoy attempting to nike air max find louboutin outlet hook a within a outhouse.

I did so all your own woman nike free got finishing, E get back home Eugene declares, Rendering barking industrial noise. You ought to staying woofing inside somebody. The particular montblanc pens contains them pretty much. Then again this christian louboutin outlet realisation overevent, Inspite of nike store all of that, Seemed to be continuously likely to be about Hoeness. Not really christian louboutin sale with the way as well as formed this advice soccer team over the past thirty nike shoes a long time, Or in which like to notable reason that he's the us web design manager within membership. It involved Hoeness merely considering the fact that all over March, The christian louboutin outlet person who christian louboutin outlet have brings together FC Bayern heading to mont blanc outlet be in the mont blanc pens courtroom and as mont blanc a consequence, Inside even worst circumstance, Could quite possibly facial air max area the penitentiary,

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.