Lesson for Democrats: Back to Class

How Democrats dismissed economic class as the politics of the past, and why it is the key to their future.

According to President Obama, the election that gave Donald Trump and the Republicans full control of the federal government and their greatest dominance at the state level since the Civil War had nothing to do with his policies. We Democrats have “better ideas,” he insisted to the press. “But I also believe that good ideas don’t matter if people don’t hear them.” Hillary, one might conclude from Obama’s remarks, just didn’t work hard enough.

The president’s argument echoes through much of the Democrats’ gloomy post-mortem. The problem was Hillary’s schedule, or not enough “get-out-the-vote organizing, or James Comey’s interventions. And, of course, the racist and sexist voters in fly-over America, who are too stupid to understand their own interest.

There is some truth to all of that. But the consoling claim that it wasn’t our product that failed but merely our marketing leads to a dangerous conclusion: that all the Democrats have to do is to organize harder and wait for the vile and buffoonish Trump to implode.

The Trans-Pacific Partnership, however, was not a “better idea.” Neither was the failure to prosecute Wall Street CEO’s after the fraud-driven financial collapse that brought on the Great Recession. Nor the timid fiscal stimulus that stranded millions in the slowest recovery on record.

To be fair, these were not simply Obama’s mistakes. They were the fruits of a culture of the implicit—and at times, explicit—contempt for working-class America that has been spreading through much of the Democratic Party’s leadership for several decades.

As Democrats ponder their future, a little history might help.
Democrats’ reaction to Ronald Reagan’s victory over Jimmy Carter in 1980 was a gut-wrenching shock similar to what they have experienced in the past few weeks. Reagan wanted to privatize Social Security, ran a racist campaign against the “welfare queen riding in a Cadillac,” and seemed willing to bring us to nuclear war with the Soviet Union. Liberals were sick to their stomachs that election night.

Trump is not Reagan. And 2016 is not 1980. But both elections were lost by tone-deaf Democratic elites who dismissed the economic anxieties of the working class.

As the unemployment rate began to rise in the winter of 1979-80, progressive Democrats appealed to Carter for a jobs program to offset the damage being done by the Federal Reserve’s high interest rates. Carter rejected the idea because Wall Street would not accept more spending.

“Aren’t you worried about the president’s re-election?” I asked his staff at one White House meeting. Eyes rolled. “Do you really think that we could be beaten by Ronald Reagan?” one smirked. “The star of Bedtime for Bonzo?” Laughter all around.

Thus—in reaction to Carter’s inaction—was born the Reagan Democrat.

Election exit polls that year showed that the chief concern of voters was unemployment. But Democrats blamed the defeat on Carter’s dour personality and the Iran hostage crisis. They were confident that Reagan’s loony economics would limit him to one term, and the blue-collar workers who voted for Reagan would soon come back home.

Meanwhile, Carter’s efforts to make Democrats more business-friendly had opened doors to Wall Street’s money. A generation of New Democrats—neoliberals—argued that because their party had a lock on the House of Representatives, which wrote tax laws, they would always be the senior partners in their relationship.

But, like Carter, they felt forced to prove their fiscal conservatism to their new financiers. Walter Mondale, Carter’s vice president, ran in 1984 against Reagan’s deficits, which were delivering jobs and growth. He lost. So did Michael Dukakis, with a similar message in 1988. He lost, too. Reagan tripled the national debt—and became a folk hero to conservatives.

It took 12 years for the Democrats to come back to the White House, and then only when Reagan’s successor, George H.W. Bush, mishandled a recession and a third-party candidate siphoned votes from the Republicans. In 1994, Newt Gingrich picked the lock the Democrats thought they had on the House of Representatives, and with it went the leverage the neoliberals thought they had over Wall Street.

That Democrats did not want to be seen as anti-business in a capitalist America was understandable. But there was another option: an alliance with industry rather than finance. By the 1980s it was becoming obvious that the United States was losing its international competitiveness. In response, a network of industrialists, labor leaders and Democrats such as Ted Kennedy and Mario Cuomo argued for aggressive industrial policies to restore American competitiveness.

Bill Clinton, running on the theme that Americans were “working harder for less,” seemed sympathetic. But for the bankers and brokers who had financed his campaign, globalization was not a threat; it was an opportunity to invest in production where labor was cheap and governments bribable.

As president, Clinton chose Wall Street over Main Street. He deregulated finance, extended privatization, and widened the revolving doors between Democrats and the financial sector. The bargain was sealed when Clinton allied with Republicans in Congress to pass NAFTA (the brainchild of Ronald Reagan), established a World Trade Organization to protect investor rights, and opened up the U.S. market to China.

Republicans and their Chamber of Commerce allies were, of course, fully on board. As they correctly saw, Clinton’s trade policies not only shifted income from workers to investors, but they undercut the most important institutional support for New Deal social democracy—organized labor.

After Barack Obama won the 2008 election as an “agent of change,” he renewed the Wall Street-Democrat alliance, persisting in the trade policies that had decimated the Democratic base in the industrial Midwest.

America’s globalized capitalism can live with the politics of race, gender, and sexual identity. But it is implacably hostile to organized labor. The neoliberal Democrats got the message. As the unionized factories closed and labor’s membership dwindled, the Democratic Party—while it happily took union members’ dues and votes by arguing that Republicans would be worse—did virtually nothing to help.

History, the Democrats discovered, was about demography, not class. Democrats would assemble a coalition of the growth sectors—minorities, women, and professional white men. Like their Wall Street funders, the coalition’s implicit antagonist, if not enemy, was the white male worker—the “loser” in the New Economy.

Ignored in this politics of social and cultural identity was that organized labor, for all its flaws, kept the white working class in the Democratic Party, and was a firewall against white racism. This was especially true for industrial unions. Moreover, factory jobs, along with government jobs, were the most important ladders of upward mobility for minorities and immigrants. In election after election, the best indicator that a white worker would vote Democratic was union membership.

So as industrial unions declined, the right wing punched through that firewall, firing up anger towards elites, whose definition of diversity and equality did not seem to include white “losers.”

As long as Republicans maintained their own aloofness to the working class, that anger had no place to go. But with a Democratic mindset that allowed Rahm Emanuel—the Wall Street fixer who staffed both Bill Clinton and Obama—to tell Obama’s task force on the auto industry bailout “Fuck the UAW!” it should have been no surprise that the Democrats were vulnerable in Michigan—and Ohio, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and Iowa.

So when Donald Trump, a man clearly unfit to be president, declared a plague on both political houses, white workers in the industrial Midwest, who had voted for Obama as an agent of change, were his.

Indeed, the election suggests that the Clinton/Obama coalition may not after all be on the right side of history. The current trajectory of the U.S. economy is for continued slow growth and a worsening distribution of income between capital and labor. If so, the politics of class may be more of a political motivator than social diversity, whatever the demographics.

The failure of the expected massive turnout of minorities and the college educated against a bigoted and crass huckster like Donald Trump becomes less of a mystery when you consider this: In the eighth year of the Obama recovery, almost half the electorate would have to borrow or sell something to meet an unexpected expense of just $400.

The success of Bernie Sanders—another unlikely candidate—demonstrated that economic pain and pessimism has already spread far beyond the middle-aged white guys who used to have union jobs. His campaign was energized by millions of young people who face a future of debt, marginal employment, and the relentless offshoring or automation of any jobs that can be done more cheaply abroad or by a computer.

As financially distressed 20-somethings become 30- and 40-somethings—black, brown, or white; male or female; straight or gay—economic class rather than social identity may well be the key to a progressive political future.

The good news is that the assumptions of neoliberal economics are discredited and that policy intellectuals on the party’s left have already thought through the building blocks of a new economic policy agenda. It includes tax, trade, and regulatory changes aimed at shrinking speculative finance and expanding productive investment in America; increasing workers’ bargaining power with stronger unions and workplace protections; and a foreign policy that shifts America from its untenable role as world policeman to one of honest broker for global cooperation on economic stability and climate change.

Moreover, there is core of experienced political leadership in Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, and others who understand what is needed.

The Democrats’ task ahead, therefore, is to return to their own roots as the party of the new working class, whose anxieties about the future are spilling over the walls that separate people of different colors, genders, sexual preferences—and even educations.

This means making higher minimum wages, collective bargaining, and worker health and safety priority issues over the next few years. It also means committing to a coherent strategy for keeping and creating jobs with rising wages in America. By moving fast to preserve roughly half the jobs that the Carrier Corporation was going to ship to Mexico, Trump has already moved ahead of the flat-footed Democrats on this issue. Democrats may sniff that Trump’s grandstanding cannot hold back the tide of globalization, but say that to the grateful Carrier worker who told The New York Times, “Now I can put my daughter through college without having to look for another job.”

Still, his pushback at Carrier is a one-trick policy. So Democrats need to keep his feet to the fire on offshoring jobs. Since he can only do this by having government interfere with the right of businesspeople to make their own decisions, it has the potential for splitting Trump from the Republicans, or splitting him from his working-class base.

A pro-worker agenda will of course turn off many of the people who paid Hillary Clinton $250,000 a speech. Democrats therefore need a strategy for weaning the party from big money, starting with overturning the Supreme Court’s decision on Citizen United.

Trump’s victory, however, locks down the Court for the foreseeable future. So, given that overwhelming majorities think that Washington is corrupted by money, this is an issue that could ignite populist energy for the Democrats if they launched a grass-roots campaign to amend the Constitution.

No such campaigns or policies can be led by a policy class that moves from Wall Street to Washington and back, and remains much of the default pool of policymakers poised to return if and when the Trump experiment collapses.

The conventional wisdom is that Trump will tank; his promises contain too many contradictions for him to deliver on them. But Democrats also made that assumption about Reagan, whom they considered over his head when it came to policy. Trump, like Reagan, recites the catechism of fiscal conservatism, but like Reagan, he may turn out to be a Keynesian spender. Certainly he knows enough bankers and brokers to understand that their economic principles are easily bought off with tax cuts and deregulation.

Any Trump stimulus will direct the lion’s share of benefits to the top 1 percent, but enough could trickle-down in the form of tighter labor markets to see a sustained rise in wages. Assuming he keeps his promise to defend Social Security and Medicare, a few dramatic confrontations over trade policy and a battle with the Federal Reserve to keep interest rates low, could cement his populist credentials.

Trump will always have trouble curbing his motor mouth, but he has already demonstrated a prowess for explaining away his failures by scapegoating minorities, immigrants, and liberals. A Democratic Party that cannot look at the economy through the lens of class as well as social identity may be just what he needs to turn Trump into a longer lasting Trumpism.              

Jeff Faux

Jeff Faux, Member of the Editorial Board of Insight, is the founder and former president of the Economic Policy Institute and the author of the new book "The Servant Economy: Where America's Elite is Sending the Middle Class".

wqThe traditional solid mcm

wqThe traditional solid mcm handbags outlet wood flooring is an nike air force arrogant prada outlet thing, nike outlet the dolphins nfl jersey requirements of kate spade outlet online the pavement is extremely dsquared2 jeans high, the ecco outlet online shop ravens nfl jersey is not good air max one or two ralph lauren years after ray-ban sunglasses the michael kors floor will new balance shoes be longchamp black friday sewn adidas online arch, long champ give you barbour jackets face michael kors to michael kors purses see. Solid ray ban wood converse lock reebok floor through a ralph lauren outlet online special cartier montres tenon design, converse shoes making christian louboutin shoes the board rolex watches and north face the board as tight as mcm handbags the tiger's nike air yeezy mouth, mutual containment. Here I am polo ralph lauren outlet more detailed understanding michael kors of the oakley sunglasses next solid air max 90 wood lock floor phoenix suns vs nike air max traditional floor cheap mlb jerseys it. The traditional mizuno running solid hugo boss clothes wood jazz jersey flooring

is tommy hilfiger an arrogant thing, the requirements nike mercurial of new balance the pavement is cheap michael kors extremely indoor soccer shoes high, the nike outlet store shop atlanta hawks jersey is beats audio not handbags outlet good one or two years after the floor michael kors will hollister co be open from the instyler arch, give you fake rolex face to see. knockoff handbags Many of softball bats the hollister shops givenchy handbags have oakley just been completed cavaliers jerseys after the floor has been arch, lacoste outlet online and patriots nfl jersey the decoration has long lunette ray ban been gone. red bottoms Some serious nike tracksuits arch phenomenon, the broncos nfl jersey arch even ray ban outlet the door are not switch. giuseppe shoes Many people mbt mens shoes even the north face outlet willing to abandon the solid wood nike roshe flooring handbags outlet and nike roche run choose composite floor, burberry outlet mostly because

of this problem. Then nike there are many solid cheap jerseys wood flooring for the timberland shoes so-called fixation, and nike huaraches extensive designer handbags use of kate spade bags glue. basketball shoes Do not know ralph lauren outlet online the wood fear of the tide, and puma sneakers glue are mostly nike free run water-based, wood longchamp floor baseball bats moisture absorption air jordans is watches canada inevitable ipad mini cases from hollister the arch. thomas sabo "Tiger's nike shoes outlet mouth" the north face solid wood floor charlotte hornets jerseys lock technology to hilfiger online shop absorb brooklyn nets jersey the ancient Chinese tenon structure air jordan shoes of coach factory outlet the excellent characteristics. Through the special tenon vans shoes design, chi hair making the board and michael kors outlet online the nba jerseys board michael kors outlet online as the tiger's mouth as giants nfl jersey closelyThe ralph lauren traditional solid wood flooring is ralph lauren outlet online an arrogant thing, the requirements of michael kors bags the pavement marc jacobs is extremely burberry sale high, the shop ralph lauren outlet is ralph lauren black friday not good one trail blazers jersey or pandora jewelry two air jordan retro years after the floor will be sewn arch, give you face to hermes birkin bag see. Solid coach factory outlet online wood lock floor through a special tenon coach outlet online design, making ray ban outlet the seahawks nfl jersey board ralph lauren uk and the board as tight as the burberry sale tiger's mouth, mutual containment. Here coach store I mcm handbags am more detailed understanding longchamp of the next oakley sunglasses outlet solid wood ralph lauren polos lock floor vs traditional floor wizards jersey it. The traditional solid wood burberry handbags flooring

is an arrogant thing, the requirements of the pavement is cheap oakley sunglasses extremely high, the shop is not good one or two swarovski online years after the air max 90 floor salvatore ferragamo will chi flat iron be open from the arch, give you coach purses factory face to see. oakley Many of the shops have just been completed after prada sunglasses the floor has been cheap clothes arch, and the decoration nike outlet has long vans been vans gone. celine black friday Some kids hoodies serious cheap jerseys arch phenomenon, hollister kids the coach factory arch even the door adidas are not michael kors handbags switch. jimmy choo outlet Many people even willing timberland boots to abandon the prada solid wood flooring nba jersey and bengals nfl jersey choose composite floor, mostly because

of this swarovski problem. converse sneakers Then bcbg max there longchamp handbags are many solid burberry handbags wood flooring cowboys nfl jersey for tory burch handbags the azcardinals nfl jersey so-called fixation, and barbour outlet online extensive use of glue. occhiali oakley Do not tn pas cher know ray ban the jordans wood fear dallas mavericks jerseys of the tide, and glue are coach handbags mostly pandora schmuck water-based, wood floor moisture absorption is inevitable from the arch. "Tiger's mouth" philadelphia 76ers jerseys solid wood floor lock technology to air max 2015 absorb the ancient Chinese tenon structure of air max the puma online excellent characteristics. steelers nfl jersey Through the golden state warriors jerseys special tenon nike free run 5.0 design, making the board toms shoes outlet and cheap jerseys the board swarovski canada as the tiger's mouth as closelyThe replica rolex traditional toms shoes solid north face wood flooring is tommy hilfiger an arrogant thing, the nike air max requirements of the tommy hilfiger pavement is huarache extremely high, the ray ban sunglasses outlet shop is not nike free good fossil uhren one or two years texans nfl jersey after the ferragamo floor will be sewn arch, give cheap true religion you face to cheap mlb jerseys see. juicy couture outlet Solid wood lock floor giuseppe zanotti sneakers through hollister a special tenon design, making the omega board toms shoes and the board as michael kors canada tight celine bags as hermes bags the tiger's mouth, mutual containment. Here denver nuggets jersey I am more detailed asics understanding of the orlando magic jersey next panthers nfl jersey solid adidas wood adidas outlet lock floor vs traditional floor it. The traditional solid wood oakley black friday flooring

is an coach outlet online arrogant jordans thing, the requirements of the michael kors outlet pavement is cheap nike shoes extremely high, coach store online the cheap barbour jackets shop nike air max 2014 is not good polo ralph lauren one or two years after the floor will beats by dr dre be open from beats by dr dre the air max arch, give swarovski jewelry you face marc jacobs to see. Many salomon of nike mercurial the colts nfl jersey shops have just been completed under armour curry after the longchamp floor lunette oakley has levi's jeans been christian louboutin arch, and nfl jerseys the decoration has long been gone. north face Some serious adidas outlet arch north face phenomenon, the arch oakley sunglasses cheap even the door nike air max are ray ban outlet online not switch. michael kors bags Many people oakley sunglasses outlet even willing to rams nfl jersey abandon ray ban sunglasses the solid wood flooring and choose composite floor, burberry handbags outlet mostly burberry outlet store because

of coach outlet sale this problem. Then there bcbg max azria are many cheap ray ban solid burberry sale wood flooring for the so-called fixation, and valentino extensive use jimmy choo shoes of toms shoes glue. louboutin outlet Do not packers nfl jersey know the cheap oakley sunglasses wood fear new balance of the tide, and glue are mostly water-based, new balance outlet wood floor moisture absorption is inevitable from the longchamp outlet arch. "Tiger's ray bans mouth" katespade solid wood coach outlet floor 49ers nfl jersey lock nike air max technology pandora to oakley sunglasses absorb nike the ancient jordan jerseys Chinese tenon structure of the excellent buccaneers nfl jersey characteristics. Through the toms shoes special lions nfl jersey tenon clippers jersey design, making calvin klein underwear the coach store outlet board and the board nike as cheap oakley the tiger's bottega veneta mouth as closelyThe traditional adidas solid cheap glasses wood flooring cheap nhl jerseys is michael kors an arrogant hogan thing, the requirements armani shoes outlet of toms.com the pavement is extremely cheap nhl jerseys high, the ray ban sonnenbrillen shop philipp plein clothing is ralph lauren outlet not good one or nike air max 2014 two years oakley after ferragamo shoes the browns nfl jersey floor will burberry handbags outlet be toms outlet sewn versace clothes arch, nike roshe give you barbour jackets face to see. converse Solid occhiali ray ban wood lock floor louboutin through a special tenon design, pandora making kobe bryant jerseys the rolex replica board ray ban and ralph lauren the board ralph lauren as burberry tight as the tiger's mouth, mutual containment. Here I am more detailed toms shoes outlet understanding michael kors outlet online of the air max next solid wood lock floor vs traditional air force floor swarovski jewelry it. pacers jersey The traditional solid wood flooring

is an coach black friday arrogant asics gel thing, the requirements of north face jackets the true religion jeans women pavement michael kors outlet online sale is nike shoes extremely jerseys from china high, the shop is not good one michael kors outlet or two years after the juicy couture floor will be open from omega watches the arch, give you face to see. kings jersey Many of five finger shoes the nike canada shops have just been completed after michael kors black friday the discount shoes floor has been true religion arch, north face outlet and the hogan outlet decoration has long been gone. hollisterco Some cheap true religion serious arch roshe phenomenon, fendi bags the longchamp outlet arch nike even coach outlet canada the door are not switch. Many oakley vault people even vikings nfl jersey willing pandora uk to abandon the tory burch handbags solid wood flooring oakley canada and choose composite grizzlies jersey floor, mostly because

of this ray bans problem. Then there true religion outlet are many redskins nfl jersey solid wood polo ralph flooring for the so-called louboutin outlet fixation, tommy hilfiger and true religion jeans men extensive use of tory burch shoes glue. Do thomas sabo not know the cheap michael kors wood fear roshe runs of the ed hardy tide, and glue are mostly hermes water-based, wood floor moisture iphone 5 cases absorption titans nfl jersey is inevitable from the arch. michael kors taschen "Tiger's mouth" solid air max one wood timberland outlet floor lock plein outlet technology bills nfl jersey to absorb nike Air Max Plaza the ancient replica rolex Chinese tenon structure burberry of ray ban sunglasses outlet the excellent characteristics. rockets jersey Through the special michael kors tenon design, making the nike.com board and the kevin durant jersey board raptors jersey as the tiger's new orleans pelicans mouth swarovski crystal as burberry outlet online closelyThe knicks jersey traditional mcm bags solid tory burch outlet wood chargers nfl jersey flooring is an arrogant burberry thing, mcm bags the eagles nfl jersey requirements of the dwyane wade jersey pavement saints nfl jersey is extremely high, the shop is not good one michael kors handbags or two years after jets nfl jersey the floor will bears nfl jersey be sewn arch, give aktienkurse adidas you face to see. Solid wood lock ralph lauren online shop floor michael kors handbags through coach handbags a special tenon design, oakley sunglasses outlet making the board and the adidas canada board horloges as tight as the tiger's mouth, prada shoes mutual containment. Here I am nba jersey more detailed understanding of the next hollisterco solid ray ban black friday wood lock babyliss pro floor vs traditional prada handbags floor it. The new balance canada traditional solid wood flooring

is an arrogant thing, ralph lauren online the timberwolves jersey requirements of the pavement hilfiger outlet is extremely nike air huarache high, the shop chrome hearts store is p90x not good one or two years after michael kors the michael kors handbags floor will be open roshe run from ray ban wayfarer the oakley sunglasses arch, cheap jordans give michael kors purses you face to see. Many of the shops have soccer shoes just ray ban been completed pandora charms after the floor has been falcons nfl jersey arch, barbour jackets and the decoration has long been gone. Some serious michael kors purses arch eyeglasses stores phenomenon, the arch even the omega watches door are not switch. Many people cheap oakley sunglasses even willing jordan to abandon the solid wood flooring and ralph lauren factory store choose composite floor, mostly because

of polo ralph lauren outlet online this problem. Then polo ralph lauren there are louboutin uk many michael kors solid wood jaguars nfl jersey flooring wedding dresses for woolrich mens jackets the so-called fixation, and extensive oakley vault use hilfiger outlet of nike glue. Do dre beats not free run know chiefs nfl jersey the supra shoes wood fear of the tide, and burberry sale glue are mostly dsquared2 outlet water-based, coach factory online wood boston celtics floor moisture absorption is inevitable san antonio spurs jersey from the arch. "Tiger's mouth" solid wood north face backpacks floor lock ray ban outlet technology kate spade outlet online to mont blanc absorb red bottom shoes the ancient coach handbags outlet Chinese coach bags tenon structure of veneta the excellent characteristics. Through the special tenon chaussure timberland design, bucks jersey making the ralph lauren polo board and the raiders nfl jersey board as northface the tiger's mouth as closely

Thanks for the information,

Thanks for the information, Very useful
pengobatan kista duktus tiroglosus

Cialis Tension Arterial

Cialis Tension Arterial Kamagra Jelly Online Zithromax More Drug Side Effects Stendra Erectile Dysfunction Wirral Buy Cialis Cialis Achat Internet Forum Propecia Precio Enfermeria Cialis Online Cs Viagra Acquisto In Farmacia Propecia Testosterone Buy Cheap Cialis Propecia Tinnitus Hair Loss Viagra E Sclerosi Multipla Cheap Cialis And Viagra Cephalexin Induced Acute Interstitial Nephritis

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.