The Schumpeter Hotel: Income Inequality And Social Mobility

The Schumpeter Hotel: Income Inequality And Social Mobility

by Branko Milanovic on 13 April 2016 @BrankoMilan
159 Total Shares
Share
Tweet
+1
Share
Email
Branko Milanovic
Branko Milanovic
In one  of his rare discussions of inequality, Joseph Schumpeter illustrated in a metaphor the difference between the inequality we observe at a moment in time and social (or inter-generational) mobility. Suppose, Schumpeter writes, that there is a multiple-story hotel with higher floors containing fewer people and having much nicer rooms. At any given moment, there would be lots of people on the ground floor living in cramped small rooms and just a few people in the nice and comfortable top-floor rooms with a view. But then, what if the guests are allowed to move around and change their room every night? This is what, Schumpeter said, social mobility will do: at every given moment of time there are rich and poor but as we extend the time period, today’s rich are yesterday’s poor and vice versa. The guests from the ground floors (or at least their children) have made it to the top, those from the top might have tumbled down to the bottom.

Since the 20th (or even nineteenth) century, Schumpeter’s metaphor has been used as a metaphor for inequality in the US, when US income inequality may have been greater than inequality in Europe. However, it was also held that US society was much more fluid, less class-bound and that there was greater social mobility (that view of course conveniently overlooked the huge racial divide in the US). In other words, inequality was the price that America paid for high social mobility.

This was a reassuring picture consonant with the idea of the American Dream. But was it true? We actually never knew it, beyond anecdotal evidence of migrants’ lives, since no consistent empirical studies of inter-generational mobility existed until very recently. But before I go to their findings, I would like to focus in very simple terms on the relationship between inequality and social mobility.

Consider a diagram classifying societies according to social mobility and inequality. From the US example mentioned above, we  would place US in the ‘high inequality, high mobility’ quadrant. It is easy to imagine ‘high inequality, low mobility’ societies: feudal societies will be one extreme example but all societies with high income differences and entrenched power of the elites would fall into this category also. So, let us write in Latin America or Pakistan in the SE quadrant. It is also relatively easy to imagine what countries we would place in ‘low inequality, high mobility’ quadrant: probably Nordic countries with strong public education that allows high inter-generational mobility while redistribution of current income ensures low inequality.

It is much more difficult to find examples of ‘low inequality, low mobility’ societies. It seems somewhat natural to think that if a society exhibits low inequality, it will be hard to keep sons and daughters of people who have just a slightly lower-income (than another group) permanently below incomes of sons and daughters of that latter group. One can even wonder what mobility in these cases really means: if incomes between people and classes differ by an infinitesimal amount and your children remain richer by that infinitesimal amount above mine, I am not sure that that kind of lack of social mobility really matters much. Perhaps some guild-like societies where occupations cannot be freely chosen but income differences between the occupations are small could be placed in that category. Communist societies had some aspects that could make them (weak) candidates to be placed in North-East quadrant.


Pakistan

So now that we have organized our thinking, let us consider the empirical evidence. Most famously, it comes from the recent work of Miles Corak, building on previous studies by Gary Solon, Blunden, Gregg and Macmillan, Björklund and Jäntti and others.  What these authors find is that there is a strong correlation between current and inter-generational inequality, or in other words, between inequality and low social mobility: the more unequal the society the less likely is the next generation to move upwards (or conversely, the less likely is the decline of the rich). So in terms of our simple diagram, Corak finds that societies are aligned along the diagonal: there are no outliers, whether the societies exhibiting the American dream or the guild-like ones.

The implication of that finding, dubbed by Alan Krueger the ‘Great Gatsby curve,’ is that there is no American exceptionalism. The comforting picture of high inequality which does not impede mobility between generations turns out to be false. US does not behave any differently than other societies with high inequality. High income inequality today reinforces income differences between the generations and makes social mobility more difficult to achieve. This is also the point of my recent paper with Roy van der Weide. We use US micro data from 1960 to 2010 to show that poor people in US states with higher initial inequality experienced lower-income growth in subsequent periods).

This important finding that the actually existing societies (as opposed to the dreamed up ones) are aligned along the diagonal of our table has two important implications. Firstly, American exceptionalism in the matters of income distribution does not have a basis in reality, and secondly we can use, with a good degree of confidence, the easily available data on current inequality as predictors of social mobility. Thus one cannot argue that societies with high inequality in incomes are societies with high equality of opportunity. On the contrary, observed high income inequality today implies low equality of opportunity.

This post was first published on Branko’s globalinequality blog.

Branko Milanovic

[url=http://sms.sherlar-uz.co

[url=http://sms.sherlar-uz.com/user/Boget/]Оптимальный столичный ремонт холодильников за наличные в Новогиреево[/url]
[url=http://ch1818.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=49691]Оптимальный столичный ремонт холодильников бесплатно в Выхино[/url]
[url=http://www.secretsocietiestoday.com/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=68309]Круглосуточный приемлемый холодильников ремонт по карточке в Балашихе[/url]
[url=http://sniper-of-group.ucoz.ru/index/8-10929]Оптимальный выгодный ремонт холодильников за доллары в Печатниках[/url]
[url=http://team-for-ses.3dn.ru/index/8-11448]Оптимальный столичный ремонт холодильников за рубли в Печатниках[/url]
[url=http://bmxsarapul.ru/index/8-6485]Достойный выгодный холодильников ремонт безвозмездно в Железнодожный[/url]
[url=http://rightsoft.ucoz.ru/index/8-11380]Качественный выгодный ремонт холодильников за деньги в Жулебино[/url]
[url=http://globus-c.ucoz.ru/index/8-9150]Круглосуточный столичный холодильников ремонт за доллары в Люберцах[/url]
[url=http://world-for-cs.at.ua/index/8-29288]Быстрый Московский ремонт холодильников бесплатно в Печатниках[/url]
[url=http://street-brosers.clan.su/index/8-47234]Срочный выгодный холодильников ремонт бесплатно в Люблино[/url]

http://wot-pricely.3dn.ru/index/8-1312
http://www.mix-css.at.ua/index/8-19099
http://www.wennx.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=39127
http://kryakergroop.ru/index/8-7530
http://orientiry.ru/index/8-13067

Не люблю спорить о Reply to comment | Insight , ну да ладно...

[url=http://www.thesplashback

[url=http://www.thesplashback.com/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=73799]http://www.thesplashback.com/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=73799[/url]
[url=http://mtg.netai.net/member.php?action=profile&uid=49959]http://mtg.netai.net/member.php?action=profile&uid=49959[/url]
[url=http://bbs.ltxinbing.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=26429]http://bbs.ltxinbing.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=26429[/url]
[url=http://el3omda.freehostia.com/vb/member.php?u=5612]http://el3omda.freehostia.com/vb/member.php?u=5612[/url]
[url=http://214n.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=25413]http://214n.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=25413[/url]

http://koshkanusya.ru/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=144093
http://elbeitleb.com/vb/member.php?u=386737
http://extrasalty.eu/member.php?action=profile&uid=5588
http://pokemongosuomi.net/member.php?action=profile&uid=8409
http://vmingtian.com/zxjy/home.php?mod=space&uid=158014

Wonderful/ Я предпологал что

Wonderful/ Я предпологал что will be ugly. Reply to comment | Insight
http://lady2star.ru/user/Loctum/
Though released apply as modernism.[url=http://radio-detali.com.ua/user/Lockenry/]http://radio-detali.com.ua/user/Lockenry/[/url] Success !

It's fine!!! Я предпологал

It's fine!!! Я предпологал что will worse. Reply to comment | Insight
http://mogilevnovosel.by/user/LocGor/
But written regarded as a new trend.[url=http://www.mama-krasnodara.ru/user/Locitarf/]http://www.mama-krasnodara.ru/user/Locitarf/[/url] Success !

Elijah you said этот

Elijah you said этот [url=http://megaupload.ucoz.ru/index/8-58946]Ремонт холодильников реутов[/url][url=http://naruto-info.ucoz.com/index/8-26652]Ремонт холодильников реутов[/url].
My son is hard on shoes, they don’t last long with him. Life was pretty hard on Tom. http://suney.at.ua/index/8-62618 do http://bbs.weilaiws.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=7192 Reply to comment | Insight
http://103fm.tt/?p=2640
http://103fm.tt/?p=2640
http://103fm.tt/?p=2632
http://103fm.tt/?attachment_id=2792
http://103fm.tt/?p=2632

prada online coach

prada online
coach handbags
coach outlet
wholesale
cheap moncler jacket
Polo Ralph Lauren
pandora rings
ray ban online
ray ban wayfarer
pandora charms
michael kors online
nike shoes
huaraches shoes
beats studio
mlb shop
michael kors uk
Canada Goose Outlet
moncler jacket
coach outlet store
Ray Ban Outlet
nfl shop
pandora australia
prada outlet online
beats headphones
prada outlet online
coach handbags
prada outlet
nike jordan
abercrombie & fitch
pandora charms
coach online
ray-ban sunglasses
true religion uk
pandora charms
top sunglasses
kate spade outlet
Nike Hyperdunk Shoes
louis vuitton factory outlet
coach outlet
landing gears
true religion
Coach outlet online
michael kors outlet
nike australia
ups tracking
prada handbags
pandora bracelet
nfl jerseys
mk handbags
michael kors outlet
pandora rings
Ralph Lauren Polo
kate spade
pandora necklace charms
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
moncler outlet
true religion uk
coach carter
burberry scarfs
pandora charms sale
Kevin Durant Shoes
michael kors factory outlet
burberry australia
Prada bags
paul smith
moncler jacket
official michael kors
burberry outlet online
Nike Air Max
oakley sunglasses
kate spade outlet online
coach outlet
Hugo Boss Online
burberry scarf
kate spade outlet
coach outlet online
michael kors black friday
burberry canada
coach australia
moncler us
canada goose outlet
moncler down jackets
nike jordan shoes
michael kors outlet
sunglasses sm
ralph lauren shirts
michael kors outlet
nike basketball shoes
michael kors canada
pandora rings
abercrombie us
ugg australia
moncler coats
ugg boots
nike jordan shoes
burberry outlet
Ralph Lauren
coach
coach outlet
burberry
salomon hiking shoes
michael kors bags
hockey jerseys
prada glasses
michael kors outlet
coach outlet
prada handbags
Michael Kors Outlet
Hermes Outlet
michael kors tote
Coach Sunglasses Outlet
timberland boots
KD 8 shoes
abercrombie outlet
pandora rings
ray ban outlet
nike air max
CHanel Factory Outlet
polo online
coach outlet
beats by dre
louboutin shoes
coach factory outlet
pandora charms
abercrombie and fitch
burberry outlet
pandora rings
prada factory outlet online
coach outlet online
michael kors uk
timberland uk
football jerseys
coach factory outlet online
abercrombie and fitch
jordan retro shoes
salomon shoes
mk outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors us
abercrombie and fitch
sunglasses hut
michael kors handbags
nike shoes australia
prada outlet
air jordan shoes
Nike Jordans
michael kors outlet bags
burberry scarf
michael kors outlet online
coach shoes
bercrombie Nederland
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet
nike id
coach outlet online
pandora bracelets
michael kors outlet
nike australia
piumini moncler replica
prada factory outlet
Kate Spade Australia
nike jordan shoes
prada outlet
coach outlet
coach outlet
pandora charms
michael kors outlet
official prada site
prada sunglasses
Coach Outlet Store
ray ban prescription glasses
coach factory outlet
ralph lauren australia
prada sale
pandora rings
burberry scarf
clk benz
coach australia
coach factory outlet
Yeezy Boost 350
Kobe 9 Shoes
prada bags
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton uk
adidas yeezy boost 350
prada bags
adidas australia
michael kors
asics shoes
kate spade
Nike Hyperdunk 2015
kate spade outlet
Mizuno Shoes
nike store
mens sunglasses
Nike Air Jordan
pandora necklace
mk bags
adidas shoes
authentic prada outlet online
ray ban aviator
mlb.com
Chanel Outlet
kate spade bags
michael kors totes
authentic prada handbags outlet
michael kors handbags outlet
abercrombie paris
cheap basketball shoes
louis vuitton outlet
nike lebron james
Nike Free
pandora rings
oakley sunglasses
burberry outlet canada
kate spade
pandora australia
michael kors purses
abercrombie outlet
chanel
landinggear
kate spade outlet
oakley sunglasses
kate spade outlet online
ray ban glasses
jordan shoes
burberry australia
shoes online sale
prada us
coach factory
Ralph Lauren Polo
Nike Air Jordan
prada outlet online
michael kors italy
authentic prada outlet online
coach outlet
michael kors outlet
Burberry outlet online
michael kors outlet
Cheap Ray Ban
flash sunglasses
coach sunglasses for women
Ralph Lauren UK
coach bags
prada outlet online
burberry purse
china factory sale
prada bags on sale
pandora charms sale clearance
kate spade black friday
ray ban new wayfarer
Basketball shoes
prada outlet
coach outlet online
ray ban sunglasses
ray-ban sunglasses
huaraches
Hyperdunk 2016
abercrombie outlet
Jordan Retro
pandora jewelry
pandora rings
lebron james shoes
burberry outlet
Kobe X Shoes
kate spade purses
baseball jerseys
air jordan shoes
Oakley Outlet
ray ban eyeglasses
michael kors outlet
oakley outlet
coach bags
pandora necklaces
louis vuitton outlet
coach factory outlet
chanel australia
canada goose sale
Longchamp Outlet
Billat
tiffany co
nike free run
michael kors purses outlet
pandora rings jewelry
Pandora Charm
pandora charms sale online
moncler sale
Coach Outlet Online
Adidas Yeezy Boost 350
kate spade outlet
michael kors australia
Nike Kobe 9
louis vuitton outlet
louis vuitton outlet
Nike KD 8
pandora charms sale
burberry outlet online
landing gear
ralph lauren uk
prada bag
coach bag
ray-ban sunglasses
michael kors outlet online
prada outlet online
pandora.com
pandora charms
coach outlet
Michael Kors Canada
baseball jerseys
pandora rings sale
nike lebron shoes
michael kors jet set tote
coach outlet
hermes uk
michael kors outlet online
Michael Kors Outlet
ray ban outlet
kate spade black friday
coach sunglasses
michael kors purses on sale
prada outlet online
michael kors
nike outlet
mcm outlet
nike outlet
pandora uk
coach usa
canada goose jacket
chanel bag
tiffany co
prada outlet prices
ray ban sunglasses
ate spade handbags
burberry us
hermes bag
burberry canada
sunglasses outlet
Hugo Boss Store
ray ban prescription sunglasses
china wholesale
michael kors wallet
cheap ray ban sunglasses
prada official site
official prada site
kate spade handbags
Abercrombie Fitch
polo outlet
michael kors outlet
prada factory outlet online
Hugo Boss Outlet
burberry outlet
adidas australia
ugg slippers
Polo Ralph Lauren
pandora jewelry
sunglasses hut
kate spade outlet
coach purses
air jordan retro
pandora princess ring
veronique billat
Oakley Holbrook
ralph lauren
prada purses
prada factory outlet online
prada outlet online
Mizuno Shop Japan
burberry online
Official Ralph Lauren UK Online Store
Nike Jordan Shoes
Pandora bracelet
nike shoes
polo outlet online
pandora australia
burberry online
pandora uk
moncler clothing
pandora charms black friday
asics Australia
kate spade canada
huarache nike
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
Mizuno Shop
michael kors outlet
shoes online
moncler jacket mens
michael kors outlet
cheap coach purse
ralph lauren
nike air huarache
longchamp outlet
burberry outlet canada
ugg uk
michael kors
burberry outlet
coach outlet
coach outlet
abercrombie outlet us
michael kors outlet
shoes sale
paul smith sale
Mizuno Wave
michael kors
ralph lauren uk
prada bags
michael kors bags
mlb shop
prada outlet
burberry outlet
mlb store
coach outlet
nike shox
moncler outlet
Jordan Retro Shoes
asics shoes Australia
oakley australia
kate spade bags outlet
pandora charms uk
Yeezy 350
mcm outlet online
yeezy boost 350
moncler mens jackets
michael kors outlet
yeezy boost 350 shoes
prada outlet online
michael kors bags outlet
jimmy choo australia
paul smith uk
coach factory
Oakley Holbrook sunglasses
yeezy boost 350
moncler outlet
rayban aviator
Free Run
michael kors outlet
prada outlet
football jerseys
ugg australia
MIZUNO Shop US
kate spade bags
abercrombie fitch
michael kors handbags
michael kors bags
Mizuno Running Shoes
kate spade purses outlet
nike huarache
véronique Billat
abercrombie outlet
brand sunglasses
louis vuitton australia
major league baseball
nike com
baseball jerseys
longchamp outlet
pandora australia
pandora bracelet
coach purse
basketball jerseys
pandora bracelet
ray ban sunglasses
nike huarache shoes
basketball jerseys
michael kors outlet
true religion jeans
nike shox shoes
oakley frogskins
Prada Outlet
ray ban sunglasses
michael kors outlet
Coach Outlet
Prada Factory Outlet
Chanel bags Outlet
snow boots
michael kors purses
abercrombie outlet
mcm factory outlet
pandora jewelry
yeezy boost 350
coach diaper bag
moncler uk
prada bags outlet
abercrombie us
Jordan retro
ray ban polarized
canada goose jacket
michael kors outlet
coach australia
pandora ring
kate spade outlet
prada handbags
michael kors tote
oakley frogskins sunglasses
moncler jacket
ray ban clubmaster
canada goose sale online
coach outlet
me adc2.16

Dude, this is really cool!

Dude, this is really cool! You definitely come with awesome articles. Thanks a bunch for sharing with us your web-site.

Dude, this is really cool!

Dude, this is really cool! You definitely come with awesome articles. Thanks a bunch for sharing with us your web-site.

Hay. Igor followed in his

Hay. Igor followed in his father’s footsteps, he became a doctor, too.

Тay. Why does she keep all

Тay. Why does she keep all those things she never uses? — She is a pack rat.
http://banneroobmen.3dn.ru/index/8-21268
http://revda36.3dn.ru/index/8-22482

Тay. Why does she keep all

Тay. Why does she keep all those things she never uses? — She is a pack rat.
http://banneroobmen.3dn.ru/index/8-21268
http://revda36.3dn.ru/index/8-22482

That's too bad. My friends

That's too bad. My friends and I get together often.

That's too bad. My friends

That's too bad. My friends and I get together often.

Disgust The party was dull

Disgust The party was dull until someone broke the ice with a joke and we all laughed.

Disgust The party was dull

Disgust The party was dull until someone broke the ice with a joke and we all laughed.

I really found your primary

I really found your primary webpage and additionally wanted to suggest that have essentially enjoyed searching your website blog posts. https://vk.com/wall394439642_51 I’m not sure what it is, but I smell a rat.

[url=http://meyz.at.ua/index/8-84546]Ремонт холодильника[/url]
[url=http://brazhnoe.ru/index/8-19578]Ремонт холодильника[/url]
[url=http://www.whcchess.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=29766]Ремонт холодильника[/url]
[url=http://rms74.my1.ru/index/8-24091]Ремонт холодильника[/url]
[url=http://ctcky.at.ua/index/8-25015]Ремонт холодильника[/url]

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.