Will euro survive next year?

Sottotitolo: 
The irreversibility of the euro is no longer a dogma..An amount of turbulence can trigger the "perfect storm" destined to eclipse the single currency.

There is a good chance that the euro will not become adult. Hard to say what can trigger the perfect storm, but the candidates are many: the referendum in the UK, the victory of the Austrian Trump, the reappearance of Grexit, a new electoral stalemate in Spain, or all these things together. But even if the Brexit will be averted, the Green candidate in Austria overturn the result of the first round, Sipras able to convince Berlin and Brussels not to overdo it too much, and finally the Spanish elections will allow the birth of a new government; well in this case we have to wait the French and German elections under a possible immigrants crisis.

The point is that the attitude of the various governments on the ECB's monetary policy (QE) and tax policies (compliance with the fiscal compact) clearly shows that what a decade ago seemed well-founded, i.e. the irreversibility of the euro, it is quite over. In a 2006 article, Charles Wyplosz[1], talking about how the euro was established and consolidated, stated: “further evidence can be found by looking at the evolution of spreads. They have narrowed since 2001, an indication of increasing credibility of the euro. The main setback has come in the Spring of 2005 when, following the rejection of the Constitution draft, a number of observers have started to ask whether the Euro area could break down. Then an Italian minister publicly called for his country to actually abandon the euro and reintroduce the lira. The Italian spread doubled, from 14 basis points in March 2005 to 28 in June; the average spread jumped from 4 to 10 basic points.” Wyplosz then concludes: “This episode confirms the previous conclusions. Yes, the markets do react to important events but no, they do not take seriously the euro break out hypothesis. Not only is the 28 spread on Italian debt very low, it is still much below the level of early 2001.”

You read that right: no 140 and 280 basis points, but 14 and 28. Today, Italy and Spain are happy to have a spread of 142 and 147 basis points, while the French spread, which ten years ago was null, is now at 36 basis points. And these values depend only on  Draghi’s "whatever it takes" (July 2012), and the ECB's monetary policy. In fact it is not surprising that the markets would reset the spreads: a single currency implies equal rates. It's true that the Treaty forbade purchases of government bonds at auction, but the normal routines of the ECB is based on such securities. So the fact that behind the public securities there was the ECB,  was considered obvious by financial operators, as well as the Federal Reserve is behind US bonds and the Bank of England behind the British ones.

But in October 2010 Chancellor Merkel persuaded President Sarkozy to make public the "private sector involvement", i.e. banks involvement in case of default of a country of the euro area, making explicit an unofficial agreement which took place at the European Council in May. In theory such involvement would have to start after 2013, the expiry of an (informal) agreement with the banks, that were supposed to keep the Greek bonds. The markets did not believe the statement in Deauville, because in Germany there was a widespread opinion, founded in effect, that the French banks, which had the highest share of Greek bonds, were selling them. A month later (November 2010) Akerman, President of the Deutsche Bank, in a private meeting with Merkel and Schäuble, said that his bank would sell not only Greek bonds but also those of the countries most at risk. So Ireland and Portugal had to get out of the financial market and ask for help, while the spreads of Italy and Spain began to rise, reaching levels that existed only before euro.

Angela Merkel has subsequently admitted that the Deauville statement was not a success; but actually it was perfectly consistent with the views expressed by the German Government. Consistent with the decision of the bail-in of private banks, decided in August 2013, and concerning all the securities issued by the banks, even before that date; consistent with proposals to set limits to the amount of sovereign bonds by banks; proposals for now rejected by the majority of European countries. And from the beginning of the financial crisis it is well-known the opposition of Germany to any form of assistance that introduces forms of risk-sharing, even when the reasonableness of such interventions is clear.

Recently seven CEPR economists[2] argue in this way: “Many countries in Europe are currently facing severe fiscal constraints that make it hard to raise new revenue via taxation. Tax increases by each member state would reduce much-needed economic growth and add a higher excess burden of taxation. From the perspective of tax smoothing, issuing bonds is thus desirable. At the same time, the refugee crisis involves costs now, in securing borders and integrating immigrants, and benefits in the future, when integrated new EU citizens contribute to the prosperity of the member countries. Issuing bonds therefore is the appropriate form of financing these expenses.”

The same economists have written a CEPR Report (A New Start for the Eurozone: Dealing with Debt) which offer a way to manage the debts of the euro countries. No doubt about the need to address the problem, just think of the Greek case. But you need not enter into the merits of the proposal, because, like previous proposals, it has no chance of being taken into account. The problem is to understand the reasons for rejection; there is no doubt that a part of the German ruling class (the Bundesbank) has a strong desire to close the experience of the euro; but, in the case of the greater part, it is more likely that it is a mix of ordo-liberal and fear of the reactions of the public opinion. When Schäuble said that the election results of Alternative für Deutschland were due to the low (and even negative) interest rate policy of the ECB, he has given an explanation probably wrong, because the AfD campaign was all about the immigrants problem. However it is clear that the Germans investors are surprised and upset, as are banks and insurance companies in the country.

Obviously Schäuble should know that to attenuate the QE, i.e. a monetary policy (too) expansive, involves the need to cancel the fiscal compact and switch to an expansionary fiscal policy, both at Community level (euro bonds) and at the level of individual member states. Since this does not happen, it is politics, in the form of some election results, to determine the monetary earthquake, although it is difficult to predict the dynamic of what will happen.


[1] C. Wyplosz, European monetary union: the dark sides of a major success, Economic Policy, April 2006.

[2] Corsetti et al. Reinforcing the Eurozone and protecting an open society, Vox 4 May 2016.

Ruggero Paladini

Economist - Professor of "Scienza delle Finanze" at University "La Sapienza" Roma; Member of the Economic Board of Insight - ruggero.paladini@uniroma1.it

Полагаю комментируемое

Полагаю комментируемое заслуживает внимания и может более того.
Не характерно популярная озвучка, было бы интересно поразмыслить об увиденном. :-)
Ремонт холодильника
http://www.nelt.ru/news/more.php?id=1348
Не люблю спорить о Reply to comment | Insight , ну да ладно...

Wonderful! I thought что will

Wonderful! I thought что will ugly. Will euro survive next year? | Insight
http://odm.su/user/LocMug/
Though released regarded as the genius.http://newsglobus.in.ua/user/LocWitty/ Success !!!

Wonderful! I thought что will

Wonderful! I thought что will ugly. Reply to comment | Insight
http://odm.su/user/LocMug/
Though released regarded as the genius.http://newsglobus.in.ua/user/LocWitty/ Success !!!

prada online coach

prada online
coach handbags
coach outlet
wholesale
cheap moncler jacket
Polo Ralph Lauren
pandora rings
ray ban online
ray ban wayfarer
pandora charms
michael kors online
nike shoes
huaraches shoes
beats studio
mlb shop
michael kors uk
Canada Goose Outlet
moncler jacket
coach outlet store
Ray Ban Outlet
nfl shop
pandora australia
prada outlet online
beats headphones
prada outlet online
coach handbags
prada outlet
nike jordan
abercrombie & fitch
pandora charms
coach online
ray-ban sunglasses
true religion uk
pandora charms
top sunglasses
kate spade outlet
Nike Hyperdunk Shoes
louis vuitton factory outlet
coach outlet
landing gears
true religion
Coach outlet online
michael kors outlet
nike australia
ups tracking
prada handbags
pandora bracelet
nfl jerseys
mk handbags
michael kors outlet
pandora rings
Ralph Lauren Polo
kate spade
pandora necklace charms
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
moncler outlet
true religion uk
coach carter
burberry scarfs
pandora charms sale
Kevin Durant Shoes
michael kors factory outlet
burberry australia
Prada bags
paul smith
moncler jacket
official michael kors
burberry outlet online
Nike Air Max
oakley sunglasses
kate spade outlet online
coach outlet
Hugo Boss Online
burberry scarf
kate spade outlet
coach outlet online
michael kors black friday
burberry canada
coach australia
moncler us
canada goose outlet
moncler down jackets
nike jordan shoes
michael kors outlet
sunglasses sm
ralph lauren shirts
michael kors outlet
nike basketball shoes
michael kors canada
pandora rings
abercrombie us
ugg australia
moncler coats
ugg boots
nike jordan shoes
burberry outlet
Ralph Lauren
coach
coach outlet
burberry
salomon hiking shoes
michael kors bags
hockey jerseys
prada glasses
michael kors outlet
coach outlet
prada handbags
Michael Kors Outlet
Hermes Outlet
michael kors tote
Coach Sunglasses Outlet
timberland boots
KD 8 shoes
abercrombie outlet
pandora rings
ray ban outlet
nike air max
CHanel Factory Outlet
polo online
coach outlet
beats by dre
louboutin shoes
coach factory outlet
pandora charms
abercrombie and fitch
burberry outlet
pandora rings
prada factory outlet online
coach outlet online
michael kors uk
timberland uk
football jerseys
coach factory outlet online
abercrombie and fitch
jordan retro shoes
salomon shoes
mk outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors us
abercrombie and fitch
sunglasses hut
michael kors handbags
nike shoes australia
prada outlet
air jordan shoes
Nike Jordans
michael kors outlet bags
burberry scarf
michael kors outlet online
coach shoes
bercrombie Nederland
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet
nike id
coach outlet online
pandora bracelets
michael kors outlet
nike australia
piumini moncler replica
prada factory outlet
Kate Spade Australia
nike jordan shoes
prada outlet
coach outlet
coach outlet
pandora charms
michael kors outlet
official prada site
prada sunglasses
Coach Outlet Store
ray ban prescription glasses
coach factory outlet
ralph lauren australia
prada sale
pandora rings
burberry scarf
clk benz
coach australia
coach factory outlet
Yeezy Boost 350
Kobe 9 Shoes
prada bags
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton uk
adidas yeezy boost 350
prada bags
adidas australia
michael kors
asics shoes
kate spade
Nike Hyperdunk 2015
kate spade outlet
Mizuno Shoes
nike store
mens sunglasses
Nike Air Jordan
pandora necklace
mk bags
adidas shoes
authentic prada outlet online
ray ban aviator
mlb.com
Chanel Outlet
kate spade bags
michael kors totes
authentic prada handbags outlet
michael kors handbags outlet
abercrombie paris
cheap basketball shoes
louis vuitton outlet
nike lebron james
Nike Free
pandora rings
oakley sunglasses
burberry outlet canada
kate spade
pandora australia
michael kors purses
abercrombie outlet
chanel
landinggear
kate spade outlet
oakley sunglasses
kate spade outlet online
ray ban glasses
jordan shoes
burberry australia
shoes online sale
prada us
coach factory
Ralph Lauren Polo
Nike Air Jordan
prada outlet online
michael kors italy
authentic prada outlet online
coach outlet
michael kors outlet
Burberry outlet online
michael kors outlet
Cheap Ray Ban
flash sunglasses
coach sunglasses for women
Ralph Lauren UK
coach bags
prada outlet online
burberry purse
china factory sale
prada bags on sale
pandora charms sale clearance
kate spade black friday
ray ban new wayfarer
Basketball shoes
prada outlet
coach outlet online
ray ban sunglasses
ray-ban sunglasses
huaraches
Hyperdunk 2016
abercrombie outlet
Jordan Retro
pandora jewelry
pandora rings
lebron james shoes
burberry outlet
Kobe X Shoes
kate spade purses
baseball jerseys
air jordan shoes
Oakley Outlet
ray ban eyeglasses
michael kors outlet
oakley outlet
coach bags
pandora necklaces
louis vuitton outlet
coach factory outlet
chanel australia
canada goose sale
Longchamp Outlet
Billat
tiffany co
nike free run
michael kors purses outlet
pandora rings jewelry
Pandora Charm
pandora charms sale online
moncler sale
Coach Outlet Online
Adidas Yeezy Boost 350
kate spade outlet
michael kors australia
Nike Kobe 9
louis vuitton outlet
louis vuitton outlet
Nike KD 8
pandora charms sale
burberry outlet online
landing gear
ralph lauren uk
prada bag
coach bag
ray-ban sunglasses
michael kors outlet online
prada outlet online
pandora.com
pandora charms
coach outlet
Michael Kors Canada
baseball jerseys
pandora rings sale
nike lebron shoes
michael kors jet set tote
coach outlet
hermes uk
michael kors outlet online
Michael Kors Outlet
ray ban outlet
kate spade black friday
coach sunglasses
michael kors purses on sale
prada outlet online
michael kors
nike outlet
mcm outlet
nike outlet
pandora uk
coach usa
canada goose jacket
chanel bag
tiffany co
prada outlet prices
ray ban sunglasses
ate spade handbags
burberry us
hermes bag
burberry canada
sunglasses outlet
Hugo Boss Store
ray ban prescription sunglasses
china wholesale
michael kors wallet
cheap ray ban sunglasses
prada official site
official prada site
kate spade handbags
Abercrombie Fitch
polo outlet
michael kors outlet
prada factory outlet online
Hugo Boss Outlet
burberry outlet
adidas australia
ugg slippers
Polo Ralph Lauren
pandora jewelry
sunglasses hut
kate spade outlet
coach purses
air jordan retro
pandora princess ring
veronique billat
Oakley Holbrook
ralph lauren
prada purses
prada factory outlet online
prada outlet online
Mizuno Shop Japan
burberry online
Official Ralph Lauren UK Online Store
Nike Jordan Shoes
Pandora bracelet
nike shoes
polo outlet online
pandora australia
burberry online
pandora uk
moncler clothing
pandora charms black friday
asics Australia
kate spade canada
huarache nike
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
Mizuno Shop
michael kors outlet
shoes online
moncler jacket mens
michael kors outlet
cheap coach purse
ralph lauren
nike air huarache
longchamp outlet
burberry outlet canada
ugg uk
michael kors
burberry outlet
coach outlet
coach outlet
abercrombie outlet us
michael kors outlet
shoes sale
paul smith sale
Mizuno Wave
michael kors
ralph lauren uk
prada bags
michael kors bags
mlb shop
prada outlet
burberry outlet
mlb store
coach outlet
nike shox
moncler outlet
Jordan Retro Shoes
asics shoes Australia
oakley australia
kate spade bags outlet
pandora charms uk
Yeezy 350
mcm outlet online
yeezy boost 350
moncler mens jackets
michael kors outlet
yeezy boost 350 shoes
prada outlet online
michael kors bags outlet
jimmy choo australia
paul smith uk
coach factory
Oakley Holbrook sunglasses
yeezy boost 350
moncler outlet
rayban aviator
Free Run
michael kors outlet
prada outlet
football jerseys
ugg australia
MIZUNO Shop US
kate spade bags
abercrombie fitch
michael kors handbags
michael kors bags
Mizuno Running Shoes
kate spade purses outlet
nike huarache
véronique Billat
abercrombie outlet
brand sunglasses
louis vuitton australia
major league baseball
nike com
baseball jerseys
longchamp outlet
pandora australia
pandora bracelet
coach purse
basketball jerseys
pandora bracelet
ray ban sunglasses
nike huarache shoes
basketball jerseys
michael kors outlet
true religion jeans
nike shox shoes
oakley frogskins
Prada Outlet
ray ban sunglasses
michael kors outlet
Coach Outlet
Prada Factory Outlet
Chanel bags Outlet
snow boots
michael kors purses
abercrombie outlet
mcm factory outlet
pandora jewelry
yeezy boost 350
coach diaper bag
moncler uk
prada bags outlet
abercrombie us
Jordan retro
ray ban polarized
canada goose jacket
michael kors outlet
coach australia
pandora ring
kate spade outlet
prada handbags
michael kors tote
oakley frogskins sunglasses
moncler jacket
ray ban clubmaster
canada goose sale online
coach outlet
me adc2.16

Hay. He told her about his

Hay. He told her about his plan in advance.

Hay. He told her about his

Hay. He told her about his plan in advance.

Sympathizing. It was just a

Sympathizing. It was just a slip of the tongue!

I can't believe it. I have a

I can't believe it. I have a job interview today. Keep your fingers crossed for me, will you?

Don't worry. You'll be all

Don't worry. You'll be all right. He racked his brain to solve the puzzle.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.